Barrister and Immigration Lawyers
Call us020 3764 1907Book a callGet in touch

Sports

How to Appeal a Lifetime Coaching Ban from a Sports Governing Body

· 7 min read

Imagine this difficult situation. You are a successful and established coach, but one day complaints against you lead to a serious investigation. A disciplinary decision threatens to end the coaching career you have spent many years building. Suddenly, you are left facing a lifetime coaching ban and safeguarding referrals, leaving you distressed and uncertain about your livelihood and your future.

Challenging a Lifetime Coaching Ban for a Sports Coach

Whilst it may sound surprising, a sports coach may have grounds to challenge a lifetime coaching ban, even after admitting the conduct in issue. This was demonstrated in a case in which we helped our client replace permanent sanctions which were imposed by a sports governing body.

In short, we did so by demonstrating that the penalties which had been imposed on the coach went further than was necessary. Although the disciplinary findings remained in place, the severe lifetime ban was replaced with a structured monitoring plan.

This case emphasises that (even where misconduct is established) a disciplinary sanction may still be open to challenge and specialist legal advice (when taken promptly and from a properly qualified legal team) can make a significant difference to the outcome of an individual’s case.

The Facts of the Case

Our client was a seasoned licensed coach who worked with both adult and junior participants, as well as serving as the chair of a sports club affiliated with a national governing body (NGB).

The NGB commenced a serious safeguarding investigation upon receiving complaints from several adult female club members. An important point to note is that whilst the complaints arose from adult club members, the coach also worked with juniors.

The key features of the case unfolded as follows:

  • Several adult female members complained about comments the coach had made regarding their appearance and body size. Concerns were also raised about jokes during training sessions and a message that caused discomfort. The coach was placed on interim suspension before receiving full details of the allegations.
  • During investigation, the coach admitted making the comments, but he denied any malicious intent, described the remarks as an attempt at banter and explained that a neurodivergent condition affected his impulse control.
  • The panel, however, found that the conduct amounted to sexual harassment, emotional harm and poor practice under the NGB’s rules.
  • It proceeded to impose the maximum disciplinary sanctions and permanently banned the coach from coaching under the NGB’s licence, holding positions of trust and handling or distributing club kit.
  • It further required a formal written apology and directed notifications to the Disclosure and Barring Service (DBS), the Local Authority Designated Officer (LADO) and other sports governing bodies.

Our Challenge and Action Steps

Our involvement began at the suspension stage and we acted swiftly. We did not dispute that the comments made were wrong. Instead, our challenge focused on whether a lifetime ban was genuinely necessary to protect participants, or whether a less restrictive sanction could appropriately manage the risks posed in this case.

The NGB’s own safeguarding policy had required ‘the least intrusive response appropriate to the risk’. We argued that the panel had imposed the most severe sanctions available without appropriately considering alternative types of measures. Such alternative measures could have included:

  • Probation
  • Supervised coaching
  • Restrictions on one-to-one coaching

Our representations focused upon the following factors:

  • The panel had failed to clarify why less restrictive measures would be inadequate to protect participants or why permanent exclusion was needed.
  • We maintained that the panel had failed to differentiate adequately between poor practice and abuse when determining the appropriate sanction and had not explained why less restrictive safeguarding measures would be inadequate.
  • We contended that insufficient weight had been given to the coach’s long service and his account of how a neurodivergent condition affected his impulse control when deciding the sanction and assessing what safeguards were required.
  • We also questioned whether the evidence met the separate criteria for notifying the DBS and the LADO, including what the conduct towards adults showed about any risk to children or the coach’s suitability to work with them. We explored whether sharing the outcome with other governing bodies was necessary and proportionate.

That said, any applicable safeguarding referral duties had to be assessed separately from the decision on the disciplinary sanctions.

Overall, we requested that the governing body reconsider the ban. If the governing body had kept the lifetime ban in place, we could have considered whether there were any grounds to challenge it in court. Two cases involving the Jockey Club highlight how that might work in practice.

In the case of Mullins v Jockey Club (2005), the High Court held that the club was enforcing its own sporting rules. That meant the procedure for challenging decisions made in the exercise of public powers (judicial review) was unavailable. In the case of Bradley v. Jockey Club (2005), the Court of Appeal upheld a 5 year ban, given that the appeal panel could reasonably conclude that the ban was proportionate.

Nevertheless, in this case the NGB ultimately accepted that the sanctions were disproportionate and replaced its disciplinary sanctions with a structured monitoring plan.

As such, this matter was resolved internally and without the need for court proceedings, although the disciplinary findings remained in place. Nevertheless, this was a highly successful outcome for our client considering his original position and the potentially career threatening implications. Our support may have also helped to prevent significant litigation uncertainty and legal costs for our clients.

Our Key Takeaways from This Case

For any coaches, athletes or other sporting individuals facing disciplinary proceedings, we believe this case provides important lessons.

  • Seek urgent legal advice as soon as possible. Prompt advice allows both the allegations and the potential sanctions to be addressed at the earliest opportunity. It is also important to obtain advice from suitably qualified legal representatives with sports law expertise and strong industry knowledge. Admitting misconduct does not mean that every penalty is justified and legal advice can help determine your position and options. This can be particularly crucial where sensitive issues, such as disabilities, might be relevant.
  • Carefully review the relevant governing body’s own policy and rules. There may be grounds for you to ask for a less severe penalty. If it requires the least intrusive response appropriate to the risk, ask how the panel applied that requirement and whether it correctly considered alternatives. You may be able to propose less restrictive safeguards that address the risk without a permanent ban.
  • Understand the realities of a court challenge. Disciplinary decisions of private sports governing bodies are generally challenged through private law. However, a legal advisor can guide you on the correct challenge avenues for your case.
  • As a club, remember to record your decision-making process clearly. A clear record of the risks which you have identified, the alternatives considered and the reasons for your sanction decision may help protect your organisation from risk and support a fair process for individuals.

How We Help Sports Clients

Sports law is a complex and niche area of practice. Our considerable expertise in sports law enables us to advise clients including coaches, athletes and sports organisations on safeguarding investigations, disciplinary proceedings, suspensions and appeals, as well as a much broader range of legal matters.

If you are facing an investigation or sanction, we can review the process which was followed, assess the decision reached and advise on the options available to you, representing and defending you where necessary.

We also support clubs with reviewing their own disciplinary and safeguarding procedures, including how decisions are reached and recorded and how risks can be managed more effectively.

If you require support contact our Sports Law team for expert, tailored advice.

This article is high-level, relates to the law of England and Wales and is for general information only. It does not constitute legal advice and should not be relied upon as such. Each case is unique and fact specific and you should seek legal advice for tailored guidance on this topic.

Back to top

Get in Touch

Leave your enquiry and a senior lawyer will come back to you by the end of the next working day. If your matter is urgent, call us on 020 3764 1907 and we will tell you straight away whether we can help.

☁︎↑

Click or drag files here to upload. Multiple files allowed.
File limit 10MB total.

Frequently asked questions

Straight answers to what clients ask us most. Still unsure? Book a free consultation and we will talk it through.

Book a free consultation

Ready to take the next step in your immigration journey?

Leave your enquiry, and we will review it within 24 working hours and come back to you for the next steps.